Research Report: Topological Quantum Matter: Self-Charging Mechanisms, Material Engineering Challenges, and Viability for Interstellar Missions

Date: 2025-12-03

Executive Summary

This report synthesizes extensive research into the potential of newly discovered topological quantum matter (TQM) phases to enable self-charging power systems for long-duration interstellar missions. The research query driving this analysis is twofold: 1) How do the topological properties of this matter facilitate radiation harvesting? 2) What are the primary material engineering challenges in integrating it into viable processing units?

The findings reveal a landscape of profound theoretical promise tempered by monumental practical obstacles. Topologically, these materials possess unique properties conducive to energy conversion. Protected, dissipationless surface/edge states, a hallmark of TQMs, offer a near-perfect medium for transporting charge carriers generated by radiation, minimizing internal energy loss. The unique electronic band structures, such as the Dirac and Weyl cones in semimetals, allow for broad-spectrum absorption of radiation and give rise to enhanced thermoelectric and thermionic effects, which are prime candidates for converting energy from high-energy cosmic particles. More exotic phenomena, such as the chiral anomaly and the influence of Berry curvature, present novel pathways for generating and directing electrical currents.

However, a critical finding of this report is the significant gap between this theoretical potential and demonstrated reality. As of late 2025, there is no established, experimentally verified mechanism within any known TQM that facilitates the efficient harvesting of diffuse, low-flux interstellar radiation. Recent breakthroughs, such as the discovery of a radiation-proof quantum phase in hafnium pentatelluride (HfTe₅), point towards a paradigm of extreme durability and energy efficiency rather than active energy generation. This material's ability to transport energy via electron spin (spintronics) rather than charge suggests a path to "self-sustaining" systems that are incredibly resilient and consume minimal power, but not "self-charging" systems that actively replenish their power from the environment.

The material engineering challenges required to bridge this gap are formidable and span the entire lifecycle of a potential device. Key challenges include:

1. Synthesis and Scalability: Current methods for creating high-purity TQMs are confined to laboratories and often require extreme conditions (e.g., the 70-Tesla magnetic field needed for the HfTe₅ phase), making scalable manufacturing for spacecraft components presently unfeasible.
2. Environmental Durability: The interstellar environment presents a fundamental paradox. The very radiation that might be harvested is also the primary agent of destruction. High-energy cosmic rays cause cumulative physical damage (Displacement Damage) to the material's atomic lattice, which can destroy the topological phase itself, a threat that topological protection of quantum information does not prevent. Extreme thermal cycling and the hard vacuum of space introduce further degradation pathways.
3. Quantum Coherence and Operational Conditions: Maintaining the delicate quantum states essential for these phenomena requires extreme isolation and often cryogenic temperatures. This is in direct conflict with the need to interact with the external radiation environment for energy harvesting and the reality of developing reliable, multi-century cryocooling systems.
4. System Integration: Creating a stable, reliable interface between the exotic quantum material and the classical electronics needed for control and data processing is a complex, multi-domain engineering problem involving mismatched thermal, mechanical, and electrical properties.

In conclusion, while the topological properties of quantum matter provide a compelling theoretical framework for future energy systems, the concept of a self-charging interstellar probe remains a distant, speculative goal. The immediate and more tangible application of these materials lies in revolutionizing mission longevity through unprecedented radiation hardening and energy efficiency. The successful realization of either vision is contingent upon fundamental breakthroughs in material synthesis, long-duration systems engineering, and a deeper understanding of quantum material behavior in the most extreme environments imaginable.

Introduction

The ambition of sending probes on long-duration interstellar missions, lasting centuries or millennia, is fundamentally constrained by the problem of power. Conventional power sources, such as radioisotope thermoelectric generators (RTGs), have finite lifespans dictated by isotope decay, while solar power becomes untenable in the vast, dark expanse between stars. A paradigm shift is required: the development of systems that can sustain themselves by harvesting energy directly from the interstellar medium.

This report investigates the potential of a newly discovered class of materials—topological quantum matter (TQM)—to provide this paradigm shift. TQMs are distinguished by global properties of their electronic band structure that give rise to exotic and robust quantum phenomena. The core research query explores how these unique properties might facilitate self-charging mechanisms via the harvesting of ambient radiation (starlight, cosmic rays, stellar winds) and delineates the immense material engineering challenges that must be overcome to integrate such a phase into viable processing units for interstellar travel.

This comprehensive report synthesizes findings from an expansive research strategy, consolidating multiple analytical phases into a single, cohesive narrative. It begins by examining the fundamental physics and proposed mechanisms for energy conversion in TQMs. It then transitions to a detailed analysis of the multifaceted engineering hurdles, from atomic-scale fabrication to system-level integration and long-term degradation in the harsh space environment. Finally, it discusses the broader implications of these findings, critically re-evaluating the "self-charging" concept in light of recent discoveries and charting a realistic course for future research and development.

Key Findings

The research has been organized thematically to provide a clear view of the potential, the specific candidate materials, the proposed mechanisms, and the profound challenges associated with this technology.

1. Foundational Topological Properties for Energy Applications

The promise of TQMs for energy applications stems from a set of unique, intrinsically robust electronic properties not found in conventional materials.

• Bulk-Boundary Correspondence and Protected States: TQMs are characterized by a "bulk-boundary correspondence," where the insulating nature of the material's interior (bulk) guarantees the existence of highly conductive states on its surface or edges. These states are "topologically protected" by fundamental symmetries (e.g., time-reversal symmetry), meaning they are remarkably resilient to scattering from local defects, impurities, or minor structural imperfections.
• Robust and Dissipationless Transport: A direct consequence of this protection is that electrons can flow through these surface/edge channels with minimal to zero resistance. This near-dissipationless transport is a critical enabler for any energy harvesting device, as it maximizes the efficiency of collecting and channeling charge carriers generated by radiation while minimizing waste heat generation within the processing unit itself.
• Unique Electronic Band Structures: Materials like Dirac and Weyl semimetals possess unique band structures featuring "cones" where electrons behave as massless relativistic particles. This structure enables the efficient absorption of electromagnetic radiation across an exceptionally broad spectrum—from terahertz to high-energy photons—a crucial attribute for harvesting energy from the diverse radiation field of interstellar space.
• High Carrier Mobility and Long Lifetimes: The quantum states within TQMs are characterized by exceptionally high charge carrier mobility and long electron lifetimes. This combination reduces the probability of electron-hole recombination, a primary source of energy loss in conventional photovoltaic and radiation-detection materials, thus increasing the potential for efficient energy conversion.

2. Proposed Mechanisms for Radiation Harvesting

Based on these foundational properties, several specific physical mechanisms have been proposed for converting ambient space radiation into usable electrical energy.

• Topological Photovoltaic Effect: Primarily associated with Topological Insulators (TIs), this mechanism leverages the spin-momentum-locked surface states. When photons create electron-hole pairs, these protected states act as efficient channels to separate the charges before they can recombine, generating a photovoltaic current. This effect can be further enhanced in certain TIs by a bulk phenomenon known as the "shift current," which is amplified near a topological phase transition.
• Topological Thermoelectric Effect: High-energy particles, such as galactic cosmic rays (GCRs) and solar energetic particles (SEPs), deposit their kinetic energy as heat, creating localized, sharp temperature gradients within a material. The unique linear energy dispersion of Dirac and Weyl semimetals, combined with their substantial Berry curvature, is predicted to greatly enhance the Seebeck effect (voltage from a temperature gradient) and the anomalous Nernst effect (transverse voltage from a heat current in a magnetic field). This suggests a pathway for converting the kinetic energy of particle radiation into electricity with superior efficiency compared to conventional thermoelectrics.
• Topological Thermionic Effect: A related thermal conversion mechanism, thermionic emission, involves heat driving electrons over a potential barrier. 3D Dirac Semimetals are theoretically predicted to excel in this area. Their linear band structure allows electrons to carry approximately twice the thermal energy of those in conventional parabolic-band materials, potentially leading to a more efficient conversion of radiation-induced heat into an electric current.
• Novel Current Generation Phenomena: Beyond these effects, TQMs offer more exotic pathways. In Weyl semimetals, the "chiral anomaly" can generate a current when the material is subjected to parallel electric and magnetic fields, offering a direct conversion route. The "Berry curvature," a geometric property of the electron wave function, can act as a powerful internal magnetic field to steer and channel charge carriers, effectively creating an intrinsic current-directing mechanism.

Despite these promising theories, a critical finding is that practical conversion efficiencies are unknown, and the extremely low energy density of many forms of interstellar radiation (e.g., an estimated 32 watts from solar wind for a 100m x 100m collector) demands exceptionally high material efficiency to be viable.

3. The Hafnium Pentatelluride (HfTe₅) Case Study: A Paradigm Shift

A late 2025 discovery by UC Irvine researchers identified a new quantum phase in hafnium pentatelluride (HfTe₅), providing the first concrete material candidate for this field of research. However, its properties suggest a different application paradigm.

• Unprecedented Radiation Immunity: The most significant property of this HfTe₅ phase is that it is "not affected by radiation." It is formed when electrons and holes pair to form excitons that behave like a liquid. This suggests that signals and energy could be carried by electron spin (spintronics) rather than electrical charge. This mechanism would render the material immune to traditional ionization damage that cripples charge-based electronics.
• A Shift from "Self-Charging" to "Self-Sustaining": The properties of HfTe₅ do not point to a mechanism for active energy harvesting. Instead, its radiation immunity and the potential for ultra-low-power spintronic computing point towards a paradigm of extreme durability and energy conservation. Such a material could enable "self-sustaining" processing units that can operate for millennia on a finite power source by minimizing consumption and resisting degradation, a revolutionary advance in its own right, but distinct from the concept of "self-charging."
• Prohibitive Synthesis Conditions: A major caveat is that this novel quantum phase was induced under an immense magnetic field of up to 70 Teslas. Replicating and, more importantly, stabilizing this phase without the continuous application of such an extreme external field is a monumental materials science challenge that currently precludes any practical application.

4. A Comprehensive Catalog of Material Engineering and Integration Challenges

The path from a promising quantum material to a functional, space-qualified processing unit is fraught with severe, interconnected engineering challenges at every scale.

• Synthesis, Fabrication, and Scalability:

  • Purity and Perfection: The theoretical properties of TQMs are contingent on near-perfect crystal lattices. Common synthesis problems, like anti-site defects in topological insulators, can create unwanted bulk carriers that overwhelm the desired topological surface states.
  • Complex Architectures: Fabricating the complex heterostructures needed for advanced devices (e.g., TI-superconductor interfaces for quantum computing) is exceptionally difficult due to lattice mismatches and interfacial chemical reactions.
  • Scalability Barrier: Current synthesis methods are low-yield, costly, and confined to laboratories. There is no established pathway for the scalable, wafer-scale manufacturing of high-quality TQM films required for integrated circuits.

• Stabilization and Operational Requirements:

  • Quantum Decoherence: While topological protection offers robustness against local defects, it does not prevent decoherence—the loss of quantum behavior due to interaction with the broader environment (thermal, electromagnetic, and vibrational noise). Preserving coherence over mission timescales of centuries is an unsolved problem.
  • Extreme Temperature Sensitivity: Many key topological phenomena only manifest at cryogenic temperatures. For example, the topological Kondo insulator SmB₆ loses its essential properties above 20 Kelvin. This necessitates the development of ultra-reliable, long-life cryocooling systems capable of autonomous operation for millennia, a technology far beyond the current state-of-the-art.

• System Integration and Interfacing:

  • The Quantum-Classical Divide: A functional unit must interface the quantum core with classical control electronics. This interface is a major potential failure point and a source of decoherence-inducing noise.
  • Material Incompatibility: Mismatches in the Coefficient of Thermal Expansion (CTE) between the TQM and its substrate or packaging can lead to severe mechanical stress and micro-cracking during thermal cycling.
  • Miniaturization and Power Management: The entire system must be miniaturized and lightweight for spaceflight, and a sophisticated power management system is needed to handle potentially variable and low-level energy input from any harvesting mechanism.

5. Extreme Environmental Degradation in Interstellar Space

The interstellar environment is the ultimate endurance test, posing relentless threats to the physical and quantum integrity of the material.

• The Duality of Radiation: Power Source vs. Destructive Agent: The very radiation intended as a power source is also the primary mechanism of degradation. This "power vs. peril" paradox is a central challenge.
• Physical Radiation Damage: High-energy GCRs cause two primary forms of damage:
  • Displacement Damage (NIEL): Particles physically knock atoms out of their crystal lattice sites, creating permanent vacancies and interstitials. The accumulation of this damage over a long mission can fundamentally alter the crystal structure, potentially destroying the topological phase itself.
  • Ionization Damage (TID): Charged particles create trails of electron-hole pairs, which can lead to trapped charges and the buildup of internal electrostatic fields, disrupting device function and causing decoherence. Analogous to how cosmic rays break Cooper pairs in superconducting qubits, incident radiation can directly destroy the delicate quantum states in TQMs.
• Other Environmental Stressors:
  • Extreme Thermal Cycling: The temperature swings between deep space (~3 K) and proximity to stars induce mechanical fatigue, threatening the structural integrity of the material and its interfaces.
  • Hard Vacuum: Prolonged exposure to vacuum can lead to material degradation through outgassing (release of volatile components) and sublimation (erosion of the surface), which can alter material composition and contaminate sensitive interfaces.

Detailed Analysis

This section provides a deeper exploration of the key findings, connecting the underlying physics to the practical engineering consequences and synthesizing the implications for future interstellar missions.

The Physics of Topological Energy Conversion: Promise and Uncertainty

The theoretical foundation for energy harvesting in TQMs is compelling. The dissipationless transport in protected edge states is a game-changer for collection efficiency. In a conventional material, a radiation-generated electron-hole pair must traverse a defective lattice, risking recombination at every step. In a TI, once these carriers reach the surface, they can be transported with near-perfect efficiency to collection terminals. This property alone suggests that TQMs could form the basis of a superior energy conversion platform.

Furthermore, the unique physics of semimetals offers avenues for harvesting non-photonic energy. The linear dispersion of their Dirac/Weyl cones creates an electron population that responds exceptionally strongly to thermal gradients, making them ideal for thermoelectric conversion of heat deposited by GCRs. The Berry curvature acts as an intrinsic "sorting mechanism" for electrons, which could be harnessed to generate currents without the complex p-n junctions required in conventional solar cells.

However, the analysis reveals a critical disconnect. These mechanisms are optimized for relatively high-flux, predictable energy sources. The interstellar medium is the opposite: a low-flux, high-entropy bath of radiation. While a single high-energy GCR deposits significant energy, their flux is low. The bulk of the energy is in diffuse starlight and the cosmic microwave background. There is currently no established quantum mechanism, topological or otherwise, that is known to efficiently capture and concentrate such diffuse energy into a usable electrical potential. The second law of thermodynamics imposes severe limitations on extracting useful work from such a disorganized energy field. Therefore, while TQMs are theoretically superior for converting energy once absorbed, the challenge of efficiently absorbing sufficient energy from deep space remains an unsolved fundamental physics problem.

The Engineering Gauntlet: From Laboratory Curiosity to Space-Qualified Hardware

The journey from a laboratory discovery to a flight-ready component is a multi-decade engineering grand challenge. The case of HfTe₅ and its 70-Tesla magnetic field requirement is a stark illustration of the synthesis gap. This is not an incremental engineering problem; it demands a fundamental breakthrough in materials science to create "metastable" versions of these quantum phases that persist under normal conditions.

This challenge is compounded by the "paradox of isolation versus interaction." A quantum processor's core must be perfectly isolated from its environment to maintain coherence. This involves cryogenic cooling, vibration damping, and electromagnetic shielding. A self-charging system, however, must do the exact opposite: it must be intimately coupled with the external radiation environment to harvest energy. Designing a system that can be simultaneously "open" to absorb energy particles and "closed" to reject environmental noise is a profound architectural contradiction. A potential solution might involve multi-layer materials with an outer layer designed for absorption and energy conversion, which then electrically powers and thermally isolates an inner, shielded quantum processing core. However, the complexity of fabricating and ensuring the long-term reliability of such a composite system is immense.

Furthermore, the system-level problem cannot be overstated. A failure in a classical connecting wire, a crack in the cryogenic housing, or the degradation of an interface semiconductor would render the entire quantum unit inoperable, regardless of the core material's intrinsic robustness. A holistic design approach is required, where the long-term degradation of every single component—from the quantum matter to the structural adhesives—is modeled and accounted for over millennial timescales.

Long-Term Viability: A Millennial Endurance Test

The concept of topological protection must be carefully understood in the context of long-duration missions. This protection applies to the quantum information encoded in the electronic states, safeguarding it against local perturbations like a single atomic defect. It does not protect the underlying physical material from cumulative, large-scale degradation.

Displacement damage from GCRs is the most insidious threat. Over centuries, the constant bombardment will gradually disorder the atomic lattice. This is akin to slowly and randomly chipping away at the foundation of a building. While the building's blueprint (the topology) might be robust, eventually the physical structure crumbles. For a TQM, this means the very band structure that gives rise to the topological phase can be altered and ultimately destroyed. The material could transition from a topological insulator to a trivial, conventional insulator, permanently losing its protected surface states and any associated functionality.

This underscores the need for a paradigm shift in material design, moving beyond simple radiation hardening (shielding) towards intrinsically resilient or self-repairing materials. Shielding is impractical against the most energetic GCRs and adds prohibitive mass. Future research may need to focus on materials that can either anneal radiation damage using ambient energy or incorporate redundant, self-correcting quantum architectures that can route functionality around damaged sections of the material.

Re-evaluating "Self-Charging": A Shift Towards Extreme Durability

The analysis, particularly informed by the most recent research phases, compels a critical re-evaluation of the term "self-charging." Current evidence does not support the existence of a TQM-based mechanism for active power generation from the interstellar medium. The breakthroughs observed, exemplified by HfTe₅, are in the domain of resilience and efficiency.

This leads to a new, more realistic, but equally compelling vision: using TQMs to build self-sustaining, ultra-durable systems. Imagine a processing unit for an interstellar probe that, due to spintronic technology and dissipationless transport, consumes nanowatts of power instead of watts. Imagine that this unit is physically immune to the radiation that would destroy conventional silicon electronics within years. Such a system could operate for thousands of years on a modest RTG, performing complex computations and managing the spacecraft with an unprecedented level of autonomy and longevity.

This shift from "energy generation" to "extreme energy conservation and durability" is not a lesser goal. It addresses the core challenge of mission longevity from a different direction. Instead of seeking an infinite power source, it dramatically reduces the power required, making finite sources last for interstellar timescales. This is a tangible, near-term research direction grounded in recent experimental discoveries.

Discussion

Synthesizing the findings reveals a complex interplay between the quantum and the classical, the theoretical and the practical. The very properties that make TQMs remarkable—their sensitivity to fundamental symmetries and their precisely ordered quantum states—also make them exquisitely vulnerable to the chaotic, high-energy environment of deep space. This central conflict defines the entire research and development landscape.

The proposed energy harvesting mechanisms (photovoltaic, thermoelectric, etc.) represent a continuation of existing energy conversion principles, albeit enhanced by the unique physics of topology. They offer a clear theoretical path forward. However, the engineering challenges of synthesis, stabilization, and integration represent fundamental roadblocks that are not on a clear path to resolution. There is a profound gap between the ability of physicists to predict and discover novel quantum phenomena in millimeter-sized, cryogenically cooled samples and the ability of engineers to produce square meters of the same material that can survive for a thousand years of thermal cycling and radiation bombardment.

The paradigm shift from "self-charging" to "self-sustaining" is a crucial outcome of this comprehensive analysis. It injects a necessary dose of realism into the discourse, steering focus away from a speculative and unsupported goal towards a tangible one with a clearer, albeit still challenging, development pathway. This re-framing has significant implications for mission architecture. A mission based on a "self-sustaining" model would still require a primary power source but could achieve durations and capabilities far beyond what is currently possible. It prioritizes resilience and efficiency as the primary drivers of longevity, a philosophy well-suited to the unforgiving nature of interstellar travel.

Ultimately, the development of TQM-based systems for interstellar missions is not a single problem but a nested set of grand challenges. A breakthrough in fundamental physics identifying a true interstellar energy harvesting mechanism would be meaningless without concurrent revolutions in scalable manufacturing, long-life cryogenics, and materials science capable of producing self-healing or damage-proof structures. Progress will require a deeply integrated, multi-disciplinary approach that couples quantum physicists with materials scientists, manufacturing engineers, and spacecraft systems architects.

Conclusions

This comprehensive research report set out to determine how the topological properties of newly discovered quantum matter could facilitate self-charging mechanisms and to identify the primary challenges to its integration into interstellar probes. The synthesis of all research phases provides a clear, albeit challenging, set of answers.

1. On Self-Charging Mechanisms: The topological properties of quantum matter provide a strong theoretical foundation for enhanced energy harvesting. Specifically, topologically protected surface states offer near-perfect charge transport; unique band structures in semimetals enable broad-spectrum absorption and superior thermoelectric conversion of particle radiation; and novel phenomena like the Berry curvature provide intrinsic mechanisms for directing current. These properties collectively describe a class of materials theoretically superior to any conventional counterpart for energy conversion.

2. On Practical Viability: Despite the theoretical promise, there is currently no experimental evidence for a specific mechanism within any known quantum matter phase that can efficiently harvest the low-flux, diffuse radiation of the interstellar medium. The concept of a "self-charging" system remains speculative.

3. On Material Engineering Challenges: The practical implementation of TQMs faces a gauntlet of fundamental, interconnected challenges. These include the inability to scale up the synthesis of high-purity materials from laboratory to industrial production; the immense difficulty in stabilizing fragile quantum states against decoherence under extreme, century-long operational conditions; the unresolved paradox of needing to isolate the system for coherence while exposing it for energy harvesting; and the certainty of cumulative physical degradation from radiation and thermal stress that topological protection cannot prevent.

4. A New Paradigm: The most significant conclusion is the necessary shift in perspective from "self-charging" (active power generation) to "self-sustaining" (extreme durability and efficiency). Recent discoveries, particularly in materials like hafnium pentatelluride, point the way toward radiation-immune, ultra-low-power electronics. This technology could enable missions of millennial duration by drastically reducing power demand, representing a different but equally revolutionary pathway to achieving the goals of interstellar exploration.

The forward-looking insight is that the pursuit of TQMs for space applications must follow a dual track. Fundamental physics research must continue to search for novel quantum interactions that could potentially solve the interstellar energy harvesting problem. Simultaneously, and with equal priority, a concerted, multi-disciplinary engineering effort must focus on the monumental challenges of manufacturing, stabilizing, and integrating these remarkable materials, with an initial focus on the more tangible goal of creating the ultra-durable, self-sustaining systems that will be essential for humanity's first true steps into the interstellar void.

References

Total unique sources: 159

ID	Source	ID	Source	ID	Source
[1]	scitechdaily.com	[2]	mpg.de	[3]	youtube.com
[4]	sciencedaily.com	[5]	mdpi.com	[6]	arxiv.org
[7]	princeton.edu	[8]	nasa.gov	[9]	mdpi.com
[10]	nasa.gov	[11]	universityofcalifornia.edu	[12]	wikipedia.org
[13]	youtube.com	[14]	mit.edu	[15]	appliedmaterials.com
[16]	researchgate.net	[17]	princeton.edu	[18]	researchgate.net
[19]	arxiv.org	[20]	arxiv.org	[21]	nih.gov
[22]	stanford.edu	[23]	patsnap.com	[24]	nih.gov
[25]	cnrs.fr	[26]	youtube.com	[27]	myscience.org
[28]	mrsec.org	[29]	arxiv.org	[30]	arxiv.org
[31]	umd.edu	[32]	princeton.edu	[33]	msu.edu
[34]	researchgate.net	[35]	researchgate.net	[36]	wikipedia.org
[37]	spire.com	[38]	nasa.gov	[39]	militaryembedded.com
[40]	alpineadvancedmaterials.com	[41]	frontiersin.org	[42]	quantumzeitgeist.com
[43]	nasa.gov	[44]	medium.com	[45]	researchgate.net
[46]	thequantuminsider.com	[47]	aalto.fi	[48]	arxiv.org
[49]	researchgate.net	[50]	metamaterials.network	[51]	quora.com
[52]	quora.com	[53]	researchgate.net	[54]	youtube.com
[55]	arxiv.org	[56]	rsc.org	[57]	sciencedaily.com
[58]	miragenews.com	[59]	medium.com	[60]	youtube.com
[61]	reddit.com	[62]	youtube.com	[63]	arxiv.org
[64]	nih.gov	[65]	wikipedia.org	[66]	youtube.com
[67]	pnas.org	[68]	researchgate.net	[69]	arxiv.org
[70]	nasa.gov	[71]	nasa.gov	[72]	astrosparch.com
[73]	researchgate.net	[74]	rsc.org	[75]	acs.org
[76]	researchgate.net	[77]	github.io	[78]	researchgate.net
[79]	researchgate.net	[80]	mdpi.com	[81]	arxiv.org
[82]	nih.gov	[83]	researchgate.net	[84]	quora.com
[85]	jcbms.org	[86]	researchgate.net	[87]	riken.jp
[88]	cambridge.org	[89]	azoquantum.com	[90]	thequantuminsider.com
[91]	azoquantum.com	[92]	rdworldonline.com	[93]	nsf.gov
[94]	fornl.info	[95]	aip.org	[96]	acs.org
[97]	arxiv.org	[98]	nih.gov	[99]	arxiv.org
[100]	psi.ch	[101]	mdpi.com	[102]	quantumzeitgeist.com
[103]	quantumzeitgeist.com	[104]	aip.org	[105]	conf.tw
[106]	ustc.edu.cn	[107]	researchgate.net	[108]	europa.eu
[109]	ieee.org	[110]	arxiv.org	[111]	optica.org
[112]	optica.org	[113]	mdpi.com	[114]	optica.org
[115]	ictp.it	[116]	nasa.gov	[117]	nasa.gov
[118]	stackexchange.com	[119]	aip.org	[120]	osti.gov
[121]	azoquantum.com	[122]	thequantuminsider.com	[123]	pnnl.gov
[124]	mit.edu	[125]	science.gov	[126]	core.ac.uk
[127]	researchgate.net	[128]	nasa.gov	[129]	nasa.gov
[130]	ekb.eg	[131]	dtic.mil	[132]	wikipedia.org
[133]	nasa.gov	[134]	nasa.gov	[135]	researchgate.net
[136]	researchgate.net	[137]	researchgate.net	[138]	jhuapl.edu
[139]	usra.edu	[140]	researchgate.net	[141]	nasa.gov
[142]	nasa.gov	[143]	cambridge.org	[144]	esa.int
[145]	researchgate.net	[146]	wikipedia.org	[147]	researchgate.net
[148]	sciencedaily.com	[149]	scitechdaily.com	[150]	youtube.com
[151]	rice.edu	[152]	harvard.edu	[153]	rsc.org
[154]	researchgate.net	[155]	arxiv.org	[156]	researchgate.net
[157]	arxiv.org	[158]	nasa.gov	[159]	ethz.ch